Disclaimer: This page may include affiliate links. I may earn a small commission from some of the brands mentioned here. Click here for more info.

Raise your hand if you never have the right ingredients on hand. Yep, me too!

Cream of Chicken Soup and Cream of Mushroom soup are just those kinds of ingredients that are hard to keep on hand. So, instead, make your own homemade substitute for Cream of Chicken Soup!

Personally, I never buy cream soups – be it Cream of Chicken, Cream of Mushroom or Cream of Celery. I also rarely use sour cream and cream cheese as a casserole base.

See all my other quick and homemade substitute recipes here!

Make your own homemade substitute for Cream of Chicken Soup

I am able to avoid these processed foods and these extra expenses by making a simple white sauce using everyday ingredients – and it takes no time! I thank my mother for this wonderful recipe – and I use it ALL the time!

This sauce takes a few minutes – and I can now whip it up without even thinking. I love to make it in a saute pan, and then directly add it to pasta, chicken, casseroles – whatever I like!  Recently I added it to mixed vegetables and shredded chicken, and served it over wild rice.  Soooo good!

(Click here to see how I make easy shredded chicken!)

Try it out – and you will never by cream soups again! I make up to two or three cups for a large casserole.

Substitute for Cream of Chicken Soup: Homemade White Sauce

Servings 1 cup

Ingredients
  

  • 2 Tablespoons Butter
  • 2 Tablespoons Flour
  • 1/4 Teaspoon Salt
  • 1 Cup Milk (can use instead ½ cup milk and ½ chicken or vegetable broth)
  • Your choice of Seasoning: S&P, Garlic Powder, Celery Salt or Seasoned Salt (Nutmeg adds a unique sweet flavor)

Instructions
 

  • In a non-stick saucepan, melt butter over low heat. Add flour and salt and mix until a nice paste.
  • Slowly add 1 cup of milk and spices, stirring constantly.
  • Turn to medium high and stir until boiling and thick. Taste and season until flavorful!
  • Add more flavor by seasoning with Parmesan cheese, a teaspoon of lemon juice, or a few tablespoons of chopped chives or parsley.
Make Your Own Substitute for Cream of Chicken Soup

Make Your Week Easier with these Deals that Keep Me Going

LeTote - I know the last thing on your mind is new clothes for you. But, seriously? When was the last time you shopped for yourself? Do you even have time to think about new fall clothes? Let me tell you what I do. I rent my clothes with Le Tote. Yep. I pick out a few outfits every month, wear them, LOVE them, and then send them back. Their prices are super cheap, and I don't have to buy anything. If you are pregnant, their maternity clothes are AMAZING. Get a free tote here and love your FREE CLOTHES!  
 
EveryPlate - I know every mom in the world is talking about Hello Fresh - but let me tell you why EveryPlate is better and cheaper than Hello Fresh. EveryPlate provides fresh family-friendly meals right to your door - but for less than $10/serving. Their meals are the same as other providers, but they use less packaging (yay saving the environment!) so they can charge less. They also offer fewer meals per week with a wider rotation, so we never get sick of the same meals! I have used them for MONTHS, and we have loved every single meal. Stop meal planning today and try EveryPlate this week with a $20 discount. Click here to get you first box at $1.66/serving!  
 
KiwiCo - Are your kids staying home this school season? Do you need something to keep your littles busy for HOURS? You need to get KiwiCo Activity Crates for your kids every month. These boxes teach your kids, provide 2-3 activities per month, give you a free storybook, and entertain your kids for under $20/month. We have loved them for years. Seriously, make this school year easier for you with KiwiCo.  
 

Latest Posts: